Both take 20%, so the fee is not the tiebreaker most comparisons pretend it is. The real differences are discovery, tiers, payout thresholds and audience size.
Free to join · Low fees · Fast, private payouts · Updated July 2026
Create your account in seconds, it’s free.
By signing up you confirm you are at least 18 years old and agree to our Terms & Privacy.
Already have an account? Log in
Fansly and OnlyFans charge creators exactly the same commission: 20% of everything you earn, on subscriptions, tips, pay-per-view and customs alike. So the choice is not about price. OnlyFans has a far larger audience and better name recognition, which makes it easier to convert fans who already know how to pay you. Fansly gives you more control, with multiple subscription tiers and free follower accounts you can upsell, and it is friendlier to niche and cosplay creators. If you are choosing one, pick OnlyFans for reach and Fansly for flexibility. The thing neither of them competes on is the 20%, which is the most expensive commission in the category.
We run a competing platform, so read our conclusion with that in mind. The numbers below are not ours, though, and you can check every one of them.
| Fansly | OnlyFans | HerFans | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platform commission | 20% | 20% | 10% flat |
| You keep | 80% | 80% | 90% |
| Audience size | Much smaller | The largest in the category | Smaller, you bring your own |
| Subscription tiers | Multiple tiers, plus free follower accounts | One price per creator | Tiers, bundles and trials |
| Payout hold | About 7 days | About 7 days, then withdrawable | Fast payouts |
| Minimum payout | From about $20 by e-wallet, higher for wire and crypto | $20 | Low threshold |
| Discovery inside the platform | Better, with tags and search | Weak, fans must arrive with your link | You bring your own buyers |
Figures reflect published terms as of July 2026, corroborated across independent sources. Payout minimums vary by method and country, so check yours before you plan around a number.
On the same revenue, neither. They both take 20%, so $1,000 in sales leaves you $800 on either one. What actually changes your income is how many people pay you, and there OnlyFans usually wins on raw scale, simply because fans already have accounts and cards on file. Familiarity converts.
Fansly can beat it on revenue per fan, and this is the part people miss. Free follower accounts plus multiple paid tiers let you run a funnel: someone follows for free, sees enough to want more, and upgrades. On OnlyFans a fan is either paying your one price or they are not there at all. If you are good at ladders and upsells, Fansly gives you more instruments to play.
Fansly is better if you want tiers, tags, in-platform discovery and a more permissive attitude to niche content, and it is popular with cosplay and fetish creators for exactly those reasons. It is a genuinely well-built product and the smaller crowd means less competition for attention.
OnlyFans is better if you want the shortest path to a paying fan. Its brand is the category, and a link in your bio needs no explanation. That reach is real and we are not going to pretend otherwise. The honest summary is that OnlyFans is the better distribution channel and Fansly is the better toolkit.
Yes, and a lot of creators do. Neither platform demands exclusivity, so posting the same content to both and cross-promoting one link costs you nothing but upload time. The only real overhead is keeping two inboxes alive, and messaging is where most of the money in this business is made.
The smarter version is to differentiate them rather than mirror them: use the free follower tier on one as the top of the funnel and sell the deeper content on the other. What you should not do is split your promotion across two links in the same post, because a fan given two choices frequently makes neither.
Both of these platforms are asking for a fifth of everything you make, forever, and the comparison articles treat that as a law of nature. It is worth a moment of arithmetic. On $2,000 a month, 20% is $400 a month, or $4,800 a year, out of your pocket. At a flat 10%, the same year costs you $2,400. The work is identical.
You are paying that fifth for one thing: an audience. If OnlyFans is genuinely introducing you to new paying fans, it is earning its cut. But most creators bring their fans with them from Reddit, X and TikTok, and pay 20% on people they found themselves. If that describes you, the fee stops being a service charge and starts being a tax on your own marketing. That is the gap HerFans is built for: the same subscriptions, tips, pay-per-view and paid DMs at a flat 10%, with privacy tools built for women creators.
Compare the wider field in our best OnlyFans alternatives guide, or read the individual breakdowns on Fansly alternative and OnlyFans alternative. If you have not started yet, how much money you can make on OnlyFans has the realistic numbers.
Keep more of every subscription and unlock.
Privacy, safety and discovery designed for women creators.
Free trials, bundles and promos to convert and retain.
Sign up in seconds with email, Google or X, pick a creator name, and set up your profile. No upfront cost.
Upload photos and videos, set a monthly subscription price, and lock premium posts behind pay-per-view.
Fans subscribe, tip and unlock your content. You keep more with low fees and fast, discreet payouts.
Join HerFans today, it’s free to start. Build your community and get paid for what you love.
